Finding the right pre-owned truck can be a challenge.
Trucks have led sales in America for 42 years, especially the Ford F-Series.
This article reviews the top five pre-owned trucks in 2024 to make your choice easier in states like Ohio, Indiana, and Kentucky.
Get ready to find your next truck with us!
Key Takeaways
The Ford F-Series, especially the F-150, has been America’s favorite for 42 years and is a top choice in states like Ohio, Indiana, and Kentucky.
Trucks under $25,000, like the 2015-2019 Ford F-150, offer a mix of power and fuel efficiency, making them an excellent value for buyers.
For those on a tight budget but needing dependable performance, the 2005-2011 Dodge and Ram Dakota stand out as reliable choices under $10,000.
Overview of Pre-Owned Trucks in the Midwest
Midwest drivers love their trucks, and the market reflects that. Our customers often choose pre-owned pickups for their value and durability.
Best-Selling Trucks in America Over the Past 5 Years
Vehicle shoppers, here are the best-selling trucks in America over the past 5 years. This insight is crucial for anyone considering a pre-owned truck. These models have topped the charts and proved their worth on the road. At Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country, we pride ourselves on offering vehicles that match our customers’ needs and expectations. Here’s a snapshot:
Rank | Truck Model | Key Attributes |
1 | Ford F-150 | Best-selling used vehicle overall, dominating in 34 states |
2 | Chevrolet Silverado | Strong performance, reliability |
3 | Ram 1500 | Close competition with SUVs in market share |
4 | Toyota Tacoma | Top mid-size pickup; watch for rust |
5 | GMC Sierra | Similar strengths to the Silverado, ranking 17th overall |
Understanding these rankings is more than just knowing which truck sold the most. It’s about recognizing quality, durability, and the satisfaction these models have delivered to drivers across America. The Ford F-Series, particularly the light-duty F-150, has been a top choice for years, highlighting its unwavering appeal.
The Chevrolet Silverado and Ram 1500 are not far behind, offering excellent performance and reliability. The Toyota Tacoma reigns in the mid-size segment but requires a careful check for rust. Lastly, the GMC Sierra shares many of the Silverado’s strengths, making it another excellent choice for truck buyers.
Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country is ready to help you find the perfect pre-owned truck that fits your lifestyle and budget. Whether you are looking for the rugged durability of the Ford F-150 or the dependable performance of the Chevrolet Silverado, we have options that cater to every need. Our inventory is carefully selected, ensuring that you drive away with a vehicle that meets and exceeds your expectations.
Choosing a pre-owned truck from our inventory means investing in quality and reliability. Our selection of the top models over the past five years is a testament to our commitment to offering the best. We invite you to explore our inventory and find your next truck with us.
Best Used Trucks to Buy in 2024
Finding the best used trucks for your 2024 purchase requires knowledge and insight. At Tom Tepe Autocenter, we understand that everyone’s needs are unique—whether it’s a workhorse like the Ford Super Duty or a versatile Chevy Silverado.
Our expert team constantly reviews and updates our inventory to include trucks that offer reliability, performance, and value. We aim to match you with a vehicle that fits your budget while still ticking all the boxes for quality.
Explore our selection, and let us help you find your perfect pickup truck today!
Under $10,000: 2005-2011 Dodge and Ram Dakota
For those on a budget but in need of a truck that can handle both towing and hauling, the 2005-2011 Dodge and Ram Dakota stand out. This pickup offers impressive capabilities without breaking the bank.
With prices under $10,000, it’s an ideal choice for anyone from Cincinnati to Milan, Indiana, looking for value. Its strong performance and reliability make it a standout option among pre-owned trucks.
At Tom Tepe Autocenter, we often recommend the Dakota to our customers from Harrison, Ohio, to Aurora, Indiana, who need a dependable vehicle but are mindful of their finances. Whether you’re carrying heavy loads or driving through mid-size city streets, this truck won’t let you down.
Plus, its fuel efficiency is something our clients appreciate, giving them more miles for less money – perfect for both work and adventure around Indianapolis and beyond.
Under $15,000: Any Toyota Tacoma (But Check for Rust)
The Toyota Tacoma stands out as a top pick for truck enthusiasts looking for durability and reliability, especially if you’re aiming to spend less than $15,000. Known for holding their value well over time, these mid-size pickup trucks offer fantastic versatility—perfect for the hustle of city driving or the adventure of off-road journeys near Harrison, Ohio or Milan, Indiana.
Before sealing the deal, we suggest a thorough inspection for rust, particularly around the frame and undercarriage. This step is crucial because even though Tacomas are built tough, they’re not invincible against corrosion.
At Tom Tepe Autocenter & Car Country, our team ensures every pre-owned Tacoma on our lot passes rigorous checks to save you from future headaches. We believe in helping our customers find trucks that aren’t just affordable but also dependable and ready to tackle both daily commutes and rugged trips alike.
With a selection that often includes various body styles—from crew cabs to double cabs—and equipped with features suited for all kinds of drivers, finding your next pre-loved Tacoma with us means you’re investing in quality without breaking the bank.
Under $20,000: 2016-2018 Chevrolet Silverado
Looking for a dependable full-size pickup without breaking the bank? Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter recommends the 2016-2018 Chevrolet Silverado. These trucks come with powerful V8 engines, known for their durability and strength.
They can handle tough tasks and long hauls, making them perfect for work or adventures around Harrisson, Ohio.
At under $20,000, these Silverados offer incredible value. You’ll enjoy driving a truck that feels robust on the road yet comfortable inside the cabin. Whether you’re towing equipment or heading out on a family trip, this is a choice you won’t regret.
Visit us at Tom Tepe Autocenter to see our selection and find your next reliable used truck today!
Under $25,000: 2015-2019 Ford F-150
The 2015-2019 Ford F-150 sets the standard for full-size pickup trucks, a title it’s proudly held as America’s best-selling vehicle for 42 years. At Tom Tepe Autocenter, we’ve seen why this truck dominates the market and particularly shines in states like Ohio, Indiana, and Kentucky.
This model combines power with fuel efficiency—two qualities every truck owner values. Its versatility makes it suitable for hard work or everyday driving.
For under $25,000, buyers get more than just a rugged machine; they acquire a piece of automotive excellence recognized across 34 states as the top pre-owned choice. The Ford F-150’s durability ensures it meets our rigorous reconditioning standards at Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country.
With options ranging from four-wheel drive to advanced infotainment systems, each truck is customized to fit your needs—whether you’re hauling gear or managing busy streets. Let our team help you discover why the F-150 remains unmatched in its class.
Under $25,000: 2017-2019 Honda Ridgeline
For those hunting for a pre-owned truck with a gentle ride, the 2017-2019 Honda Ridgeline emerges as a standout choice. At Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country, we’ve seen how iSeeCars’ analysis of 9.2 million used car sales highlights its appeal.
With its unique combination of car-like comfort and truck utility under $25,000, this model has become a favorite among Midwestern drivers seeking value without compromising on performance.
Our team appreciates the Ridgeline for its clever features, like the in-bed trunk and dual-action tailgate that set it apart from typical pickups. It rides smoothly like an SUV but works hard like any mid-size truck should—perfect for exploring Harrison, Ohio’s diverse landscapes or hauling gear for off-roader adventures.
Plus, it’s fuel-efficient compared to heavy-duty trucks, making it an ideal pick whether you’re eyeing compact pickups or are drawn by the versatility minivans lack but need more than what sedans offer.
Top 5 Best & Worst Used Trucks to Buy in 2024
Choosing the best and worst used trucks for 2024 is crucial, whether you’re eyeing a powerhouse for towing or a reliable daily driver. Our top pick, the 2011 Ford Super Duty, leads the pack with unmatched strength and durability.
On the flip side, steer clear of the 2006 Nissan Titan due to its known issues. Curious about more options? We’ve carefully curated lists at Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country to meet all your truck-shopping needs—providing you with both reliability and power on your next adventure.
Best: 2011 Ford Super Duty
The 2011 Ford Super Duty stands out for its robust powertrain and exceptional durability, making it the top pick for heavy hauling. With prices ranging from $8,518 to $10,263 for the F-250 model and $9,621 to $13,800 for the F-350 model, these trucks offer great value.
They are designed to tackle tough jobs that other trucks might struggle with. Whether you’re pulling a large trailer or carrying heavy loads in the truck bed, this vehicle won’t let you down.
At Tom Tepe Autocenter & Car Country, we recommend the 2011 Ford Super Duty to anyone in need of a reliable and powerful truck. Its capability on and off-road is matched by a few others in its class.
We see customers satisfied with their purchase because this truck consistently delivers performance they can count on. If you’re looking for a pre-owned truck that goes beyond expectations in toughness and reliability, consider adding this one to your shortlist—especially if heavy lifting is part of your regular routine.
Worst: 2006 Nissan Titan
The 2006 Nissan Titan falls short of a reliable choice for pre-owned truck buyers. It’s known for its low-reliability scores, which stem from frequent mechanical issues and high maintenance costs.
These problems can make ownership more of a hassle than a convenience. For anyone looking at used trucks, avoiding models with known issues like the 2006 Titan ensures you get better value for your money.
At our Tom Tepe Autocenter & Car Country, we prioritize offering vehicles that meet your expectations for quality and reliability. While the Nissan Titan might have attractions such as ample cab space and powerful towing capabilities, its drawbacks overshadow these benefits.
Considering alternatives that provide both performance and dependability is important in making an informed purchase decision. Opting for trucks with higher reliability ratings will save you time and money in the long run, ensuring you enjoy your vehicle without constant trips to the service center.
Explore Our Pre-Owned Truck Inventory at Tom Tepe Autocenter
Tom Tepe Autocenter is your go-to spot in Milan, Indiana, for top-quality pre-owned trucks. We have a diverse selection that includes everything from the rugged Ford F-150 and the reliable Toyota Tacoma to versatile options like the Chevrolet Colorado and the GMC Canyon.
Whether you need a truck with four-wheel drive for tough jobs or a fuel-efficient model for everyday use, our inventory has something for every shopper.
Our team understands that buying a truck is a big decision. That’s why we’re here to help you find the perfect match within your budget. With prices ranging from $10,000 to under $25,000, we offer trucks that fit various financial needs without compromising on quality.
Visit us at 426 E Indian Trail in Milan or call (812) 654-3001 to learn more about our selection of pre-owned trucks today. Check out our website, tomtepe.com, for detailed information on available models and deals that can’t be missed!
Financing Your Used Truck Purchase
Financing your next used truck can be easy and affordable. Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter offers great finance deals that help you save money. You might find zero percent financing for certain models, like the Ford F-150 Lightning or GMC Sierra 2500HD.
These deals last for a set period, usually several years, making your monthly payments more manageable. Also, look for cash-back deals on trucks such as the Honda Ridgeline.
Our dealership partners with the U.S. News Best Price Program to make sure you get low monthly payments and the best local prices on pre-owned trucks, including favorites like Toyota Tacoma and Chevrolet Silverado 2500 HD.
This partnership helps our customers drive off in their ideal truck without breaking the bank. With these options, getting behind the wheel of a reliable pre-owned truck has never been easier.
How to Get the Best Trade-In Value for Your Truck
Getting the best trade-in value for your truck involves more than just driving up to the dealership. At Tom Tepe Autocenter, we guide you through steps to maximize your truck’s worth.
Gather all maintenance records - Show us how well you’ve cared for your truck, from regular oil changes to major repairs.
Clean it up - A clean truck, inside and out, makes a great first impression. Give it a thorough wash and vacuum before bringing it in.
Fix minor issues - Small problems like a burnt-out light bulb or a tear in the upholstery can lower your truck’s value. Fixing them shows attention to detail.
Know your truck’s worth - Use resources like Kelley Blue Book to understand what your model usually sells for based on its condition and mileage.
Highlight its features - Tell us about any special features or upgrades, like four-wheel drive, low mileage, or a Denali trim package that could increase its value.
Choose the right time - Demand for trucks can vary throughout the year. We can help you determine the best time to get maximum value.
Be upfront about its history - Honesty is key; let us know about any past accidents or major repairs. This transparency builds trust and can positively impact the valuation process.
8. In-depth knowledge of what similar models sell for helps as well, noting details like fuel economy ratings or towing capacity compared with others.
At Tom Tepe Autocenter, our team values honesty and transparency during the trade-in process. We strive to offer fair valuations that reflect your truck’s true market value, ensuring you feel confident in your next vehicle purchase with us.
How to Avoid a Lemon & Buy a Reliable Used Truck
Checking a used truck’s maintenance history, getting it inspected by a mechanic, and test driving can help you avoid buying a lemon. Learn more about how we make sure none of our trucks are lemons at Tom Tepe Autocenter & Car Country.
Reliable Used Trucks for Sale at Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country
At Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country, we pride ourselves on offering a selection of reliable used trucks that meet the needs of every shopper. Our inventory spans various brands like Chevy, GMC, and Ram, ensuring you find the perfect truck for your lifestyle.
With options featuring adjustable pedals, alloy wheels, automatic climate control, blind-spot monitors, heated steering wheels, navigation systems, and rearview cameras—you’re sure to discover a truck equipped just for you.
Our standout models include the powerful 2020 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT Double Cab 4WD and the versatile 2012 Chevrolet Colorado 1LT.
Our team works tirelessly to ensure each vehicle meets our high standards before it makes its way onto our lot in locations such as Harrison, OH; Aurora, IN; and Milan, IN. With financing options available for qualified customers on approved credit, owning your dream truck has never been easier.
Whether you need a compact pickup like the Ford Maverick or something with serious towing power like the Ford F-250 Super Duty—we have you covered. Let us help guide you to your next dependable pre-owned truck today at Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country.
Tips on Choosing a Reliable Used Truck
Choosing a reliable used truck requires careful consideration. Here are essential tips to guide you through the process:
Check for High-Reliability Ratings: Look for models like the 2022 Toyota Tacoma, known for top marks in reliability. This model stands out as a benchmark in the industry.
Inspect Replacement Part Availability: Consider trucks like the 2014–2018 Chevrolet Silverado 1500, which boasts easy parts availability due to its common use in fleet services.
Evaluate Engine and Size Improvements: Trucks such as the 2007–2013 Toyota Tundra saw significant upgrades in engine options and vehicle size, enhancing their value on the pre-owned market.
Assess Value and Towing Capabilities: The Ram 2500/3500 models from 2003‒2018, equipped with a Cummins turbodiesel engine, offer exceptional value and towing power.
Beware of Problematic Models: Stay away from older versions of the Ford Super Duty with diesel engines; they have been known to face various issues.
Perform Thorough Inspections for Rust: Specifically with any Toyota Tacoma model, always conduct a detailed check for rust, which can be a common problem.
Consider Budget Wisely: Your budget will largely influence your choice, so understand what each price range offers—from under $10,000 options like Dodge and Ram Dakota (2005-2011) to choices under $25,000 like the Ford F-150 (2015-2019).
Understand Different Body Types: Be clear whether you need a regular cab for basic needs, an extended cab for extra space, or a crew cab for maximum seating capacity.
Think About Fuel Type and Efficiency: With rising fuel costs, consider trucks with alternative fuel types like hybrids or those with efficient diesel engines such as Duramax Diesel V8s found in some Chevy models.
Assess Technology and Features Needs: Determine if modern tech features are crucial for your daily operations or if basic functionality meets your requirements.
11. Prioritize Safety Features: Advanced safety features can be limited in older models, but trucks that offer solid basic safety equipment should be prioritized.
12. Factor in Resale Value and Depreciation Rates: Some trucks hold their value better than others—models like Ford Rangers and Jeep Gladiators tend to depreciate slower than average.
These steps will help you find a used truck that matches your needs at Tom Tepe Autocenter & Car Country. Our team is ready to assist you every step of the way, ensuring you drive home satisfied with your purchase.
Conclusion
Finding the right pre-owned truck in the Midwest just got easier. Our list for 2024 shows you don’t need to break the bank to get a great vehicle. From Dodge and Ram Dakota for those on a tight budget to high-end options like the Ford F-150, there’s something for everyone.
And with trucks topping sales charts, their durability and performance aren’t in question. At Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country, we’re here to guide you through every step—selecting your ideal truck, financing your purchase, and ensuring you drive away happy.
Our team believes everyone deserves a reliable ride that fits their needs and budget!
FAQs
1. What makes the Ford F-150 a standout among pre-owned trucks in 2024?
The Ford F-150 shines due to its robust four-wheel drive, versatile configurations, and advanced tech features. Its reputation for durability makes it a top pick at Tom Tepe Autocenter.
2. Why should I consider a Nissan Frontier from Car Country?
For those seeking reliability combined with affordability, the Nissan Frontier stands out. It’s known for its rugged build and efficient performance, making it an ideal choice for both work and adventure.
3. Can you tell me about eco-friendly options among your top 5 pre-owned trucks?
Absolutely! The Ford F150 Lightning and GMC Hummer, with their electric powertrains, offer powerful performance without sacrificing efficiency. These EVs provide an excellent balance of strength and sustainability.
4. How does the RAM Power Wagon compare to other trucks in terms of off-road capability?
The RAM Power Wagon is built for rough terrain and features a formidable four-wheel-drive system that tackles challenging conditions effortlessly. It is a favourite for outdoor enthusiasts visiting our dealership.
5. What advantages do compact pickup trucks like the Ford Maverick offer?
Compact pickups such as the Ford Maverick are perfect for those who appreciate versatility—a smooth ride around Harrison, Ohio or handling light-duty tasks with ease while offering better fuel economy than their larger counterparts.
6. Are there any benefits to choosing a pre-owned crossover SUV or compact crossover from your selection?
Yes! Models like the Ford Escape and Bronco Sport combine comfort, space, and efficiency—ideal for families looking to navigate city streets or embark on weekend getaways confidently.
Harry Tepe, Owner and Dealer Principal, Tom Tepe Autocenter
Harry Tepe is a seasoned automotive expert and the owner of Tom Tepe Autocenter, a leading vehicle dealership serving the Midwest states of Ohio, Indiana, and Kentucky. With a lifelong passion for automobiles.
Over the years, Harry worked his way up through various roles, absorbing valuable insights into sales management and dealership operations until he became the youngest GM Dealer Principal and owner of Tom Tepe Autocenter, expanding the business to include multiple locations and a standalone reconditioning center.
Under Harry's leadership, Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country in Aurora and Harrison, Ohio, have grown exponentially, selling over 2000 vehicles annually and generating over $50 million in revenue. His active involvement in the industry is further evidenced by his participation in the NADA 20 Group and his influential role on the Board of Directors for the Indiana Auto Dealers Association, even serving as its President in 2016.
Harry's journey embodies the essence of expertise, authority, and trustworthiness. His insights and experiences are not just stories of personal growth and business success; they are testaments to his deep understanding of and commitment to the automotive industry.
Comments