Indiana's Used SUV Showdown: Honda CR-V Vs. Toyota RAV4 – Which Is More Reliable After 50k Miles?
- Harry Tepe
- Sep 10
- 14 min read
Picking the right small SUV can be tough, especially after 50,000 miles on Midwest roads. Many Indiana drivers wonder if the Used Honda CR-V is more reliable than the Toyota RAV4 for Ohio and Kentucky families as well.
This guide from Tom Tepe Autocenter compares real ownership facts, reliability ratings, and expert reviews to help you choose with confidence. Find out which used SUV keeps its value and meets your needs best.
Key Takeaways
The Honda CR-V gets a reliability rating of 4.5 out of 5, making it one of the top choices for used SUVs in Indiana. It has lower repair costs and fewer problems reported than many rivals.
Toyota RAV4's predicted reliability score is 80 out of 100 from J.D. Power, and it offers strong performance with a more powerful engine compared to the CR-V. Its hybrid model leads in fuel efficiency at 40 MPG combined.
Both models are popular among Indiana drivers for their durability and ability to handle Midwest roads. They offer advanced safety features, tech upgrades like touchscreen media systems, and adaptive cruise control to enhance driving safety and convenience.
The CR-V provides more passenger space and higher-quality interior materials, while the RAV4 stands out for its adventure-focused design and standard all-wheel drive options on some trims.
Financing options are available at Tom Tepe Autocenter for both vehicles, facilitating easier purchases or trade-ins for customers.
Why Compare the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4?
Many drivers in Indiana ask us which small sport utility vehicle is best for them. Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 top our list because they both have strong records for staying on the road after years of use.
Popularity among Indiana drivers
Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 are top picks for Indiana drivers. Both models lead the used SUV market in places like Indianapolis, Milan, Aurora, and Cincinnati. Shoppers value these compact SUVs for their solid reliability and practical size.
Families and commuters trust them to handle Indiana’s weather without trouble.
Local demand stays high at Tom Tepe Autocenter. Many customers trade in CR-Vs or RAV4s only to buy another later. The strong resale values mean quick sales and limited stock across Harrison, Ohio, Lawrenceburg, and beyond.
Both vehicles have become staples for those needing affordable transportation that lasts through years of use.
Now let’s look closer at each model’s reputation for reliability after 50k miles.
Reputation for reliability and durability
Both the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 earn strong marks for reliability and durability, making them top picks for small SUV shoppers in Aurora, Indiana and Milan, Indiana. J.D. Power gives the CR-V a predicted reliability score of 84 out of 100, beating the RAV4’s score of 80.
RepairPal ranks both models among the three best compact SUVs for reliability. The CR-V holds a rating of 4.5 out of 5.0, placing it second out of 26; the RAV4 sits just behind with a rating of 4.0.
Drivers can count on both vehicles to last beyond 50,000 miles without big problems or costly repairs, according to many Used Honda CR-V reviews and Used Toyota RAV4 reviews from real owners.
Both SUVs also stand among leaders in owner satisfaction based on data from Consumer Reports and J.D. Power year after year. These high scores come from years of proven performance across tough Midwest roads and weather conditions seen often around Aurora, Indiana and Milan, Indiana—a key reason these two are always at the heart of any smart Honda CR-V vs Toyota RAV4 comparison at Tom Tepe Autocenter & Car Country.
Reliability After 50k Miles
After 50,000 miles, both the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 show strong dependability according to real-world data. Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter trusts these models for their solid track records in Indiana’s changing weather.
Honda CR-V: Maintenance history and reliability ratings
Honda CR-V holds a Honda CR-V reliability rating of 4.5 out of 5.0, ranking 2nd among compact SUVs and showing strong dependability for Indiana drivers. Most repairs are minor, with only 9% considered urgent, and the average annual repair cost is just $407.
Routine service visits are low at only 0.3 times per year. Out of all reviews, 83% recommend the CR-V as a trusted choice for long-term use at Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country.
“The Honda CR-V keeps going strong after thousands of miles,” says Harry Tepe.
Turbocharged engines became available in higher trims after the major redesign in 2017, giving shoppers more options while keeping maintenance needs simple and predictable. This above-average reliability verdict makes it a top pick in our lineup for any shopper focused on value past the first fifty thousand miles.
Toyota RAV4: Maintenance history and reliability ratings
J.D. Power gives the Toyota RAV4 a predicted reliability score of 80 out of 100. This places it in the "Great" category for dependability among compact SUVs. The average annual repair cost is $429, which stays lower than many rivals after hitting 50,000 miles.
Owners and our team have seen strong reliability with model years like 2017 and 2018, thanks to quality parts and engine design.
The Toyota RAV4 Reliability Rating sits at 4.0 out of 5.0 and ranks third out of twenty-six compact SUVs tested by RepairPal’s experts. Maintenance records show fewer issues on these models after long use compared to older ones from 2001, 2002, 2007, or 2008 that had more problems over time.
Safety confidence also remains high; both RAV4 and CR-V scored an impressive safety rating of 8.7 out of ten in recent vehicle evaluations completed by industry groups like J.D Power and other evaluators trusted by Tom Tepe Autocenter & Car Country shoppers looking for small sport utility vehicles with solid reliability ratings.
Performance and Fuel Efficiency
Both the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 give you strong engine options that make driving easy in city streets or on Indiana highways. Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter knows these crossovers also help save gas, which can keep costs down over time.
Engine performance comparison
Engine output and driving feel matter for Indiana SUV buyers. Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter compared key engine specs of the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 to help you decide.
Feature | 2019 Honda CR-V | 2019-2020 Toyota RAV4 |
Base Engine | 2.4-liter I4 | 2.5-liter I4 |
Turbo Option | 1.5-liter turbo-four | Not available |
Horsepower | 184 HP (2.4L) / 190 HP (1.5L Turbo) | 203 HP |
Torque | 180 lb-ft (2.4L) / 179 lb-ft (1.5L Turbo) | 184 lb-ft |
Transmission | CVT | 8-speed automatic |
Driving Feel | Agile, precise body control, smooth turbo power | Smooth, responsive shifts, more power for acceleration |
All-Wheel Drive Capability | Available | Standard on some trims with variable torque distribution (Adventure/TRD Off-Road) |
Towing & Hauling | Best for daily driving | Stronger for towing, hauling, and light off-road |
Shoppers across Indiana appreciate the CR-V’s turbocharged zip and the RAV4’s extra power. The eight-speed in the RAV4 earns praise for crisp shifts. CR-V’s handling stays nimble and responsive, ideal for tight turns and smooth commutes. RAV4’s extra horsepower and torque offer better acceleration and towing, with adventure-ready trims for those who want to explore.
Interior Space and Comfort
Both the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 seat five, but each offers its own approach to comfort and room for families. Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter can help you explore cargo flexibility and seating upgrades that fit your lifestyle.
Honda CR-V: Passenger and cargo space
Honda CR-V packs 106.0 cubic feet of passenger space, giving everyone more room than you get in a Toyota RAV4. Rear seat riders have over three extra inches of legroom, so adults sit comfortably on long drives.
Up front and in back, the seats offer strong support and good headroom even for taller folks.
You will find up to 76.5 cubic feet of cargo with seats folded down. The load floor sits low, making it easy to pack groceries or gear at Tom Tepe Autocenter & Car Country before your next trip through Indiana.
Materials inside the CR-V look and feel more upscale than rival small SUVs. Families enjoy this roomy interior every day—whether taking kids to school or heading out for weekend fun.
Toyota RAV4: Passenger and cargo space
The RAV4 offers 69.8 cubic feet of cargo space with the rear seats folded down, making it great for gear or luggage. Its cabin has a rugged and adventure-focused design that appeals to drivers who like outdoor trips around Indiana.
Large storage bins and cupholders keep small items handy on busy days. The 2019 RAV4 XLE features a continuous flow interior design and wide windows for good visibility.
Passenger comfort is solid but not perfect. The front passenger seat does not adjust as much as in the CR-V, which may matter if you want more seating options. Some hard plastic surfaces are present inside, so it feels less plush than others in its class.
Still, the RAV4 works well for daily driving and quick weekend getaways.
Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter knows families appreciate roomy interiors—RAV4 makes packing up easy.
Technology and Safety Features
Both the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 offer touchscreen media systems, Bluetooth hands-free tech, and adaptive cruise control for peace of mind. You can also find lane-keeping assist and blind spot monitors on many models, giving Indiana drivers helpful tools for safer trips.
Advanced safety systems in the CR-V
The Honda CR-V comes with Honda Sensing, a group of safety features that help keep drivers and passengers safe. This system includes adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assist, and forward-collision warning with automatic emergency braking.
Since 2020, every CR-V trim has these advanced safety systems as standard equipment; in 2019, all trims except the LX included them.
Safety experts give the CR-V a score of 8.7 out of 10 for overall protection. These features work well every day and do not fail often. They are one reason owners trust the CR-V after driving over 50,000 miles.
High owner satisfaction shows how much drivers value this technology on Indiana roads. Tom Tepe Autocenter offers small SUVs like the CR-V for shoppers focused on safety and reliability after years of use.
Premium tech features in the RAV4
Moving from safety in the CR-V, shoppers often ask about tech in the Toyota RAV4. Every trim of the 2019 RAV4 comes with a large touchscreen system. Apple CarPlay is included on all models starting in 2019, while Android Auto joined as standard in 2020.
Higher trims offer wireless smartphone integration and built-in navigation—great for road trips across Indiana.
RAV4 makes things easy to use; its infotainment touchscreen responds faster than many others. Upper trims, like Adventure and TRD Off-Road, include smart traction features to help handle rough roads or snow days.
Toyota Safety Sense appears on every version, boosting peace of mind for families and commuters.
“Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter sees how buyers love these convenient upgrades.”
Extra technology boosts resale value and market demand for used RAV4 SUVs. Premium options remain more available compared to their Honda rival, making it easier for drivers to find what they want without compromise.
Resale Value and Depreciation
Both the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 hold their worth well after 50,000 miles. Many Indiana drivers see a strong trade-in value when they upgrade at Tom Tepe Autocenter or Car Country.
CR-V’s long-term value retention
The Honda CR-V stands out for keeping its value over time. Its average annual repair cost is only $407, which is lower than the Toyota RAV4. The CR-V holds a strong predicted reliability score of 84 out of 100, making it more appealing to buyers who want lasting dependability.
CR-V owners often praise its roomy interior and comfort features, adding extra appeal for years of use. Updates like the recent redesign keep these SUVs popular in Indiana’s used SUV market.
High owner satisfaction rates help boost resale value at Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country. For shoppers focused on long-term savings and reliability, the CR-V continues to be a smart pick.
RAV4’s market value and demand
Toyota RAV4s hold their value well in Indiana. Used RAV4s attract strong demand with prices staying high due to low average annual repair costs of about $429 and a tough reputation.
Many shoppers choose the hybrid models, which get up to 40 miles per gallon combined. These features push up resale values across trims.
Shoppers appreciate the Adventure and TRD Off-Road options for rugged driving. High horsepower at 203 and fuel economy (27 city, 35 highway MPG) also help boost desirability. A base price under $30,000 fits many budgets, while premium tech draws even more buyers looking for top features in a small SUV.
Some drivers notice simple interior materials, but this rarely affects overall demand thanks to Toyota’s trusted name and popular infotainment system. At Tom Tepe Autocenter, these factors make sourcing good used RAV4 inventory both competitive and exciting for our team and clients alike.
Which SUV is the Right Fit for You?
Both the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 handle Indiana roads with ease. Our team at Tom Tepe Autocenter helps you compare reliability, comfort features, vehicle history reports, and real customer reviews to decide which one meets your needs.
CR-V for comfort and efficiency
The Honda CR-V gives drivers in Indiana a smooth and quiet ride. It stands out with its roomy interior, higher-quality materials, and more comfortable seats than the Toyota RAV4. Passengers get extra space to stretch out, while 39.2 cubic feet of cargo capacity makes packing for trips much easier.
Fuel savings help families and commuters keep costs down too. The CR-V gets a city rating of 28 miles per gallon, slightly better than the RAV4’s 27 MPG. Standard safety tech on recent models helps protect every drive across Indiana roads.
Comfort is key when you spend hours behind the wheel; that’s why we at Tom Tepe Autocenter recommend the Honda CR-V for those who want generous space and top fuel efficiency.
RAV4 for power and features
RAV4 offers more power with a 2.5-liter engine that makes 203 horsepower, beating the CR-V’s 190-horsepower rating. Families who need to tow or haul gear will benefit from this boost in strength and faster acceleration.
RAV4 models like Adventure and TRD Off-Road give extra grip with upgraded all-wheel drive and smart torque control.
RAV4 shines when it comes to tech features. It has a bigger touchscreen than the CR-V, plus easy-to-use wireless smartphone pairing and built-in navigation on most trims. Every base model costs less than $30,000, giving you great value for all these extras.
The infotainment system is simple for drivers of any age to use. For shoppers who want strong performance and advanced features at Tom Tepe Autocenter or Car Country, RAV4 stands out as a smart pick in Indiana’s small SUV market.
Financing Your SUV Purchase
Our finance team guides drivers through choices like low-rate loans and flexible payment plans. Reach out to discover which auto credit option fits your needs best at Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country.
Explore Financing Options at Tom Tepe Autocenter
Getting the right SUV within your budget is important. At Tom Tepe Autocenter, we make it easy and clear for you.
We offer financing for both the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4. Our team helps find loans with good rates.
We have options for most credit situations. We work with various lenders.
Applying online for pre-approval saves time. It makes the process faster.
You get personalized financing plans. We look at what you need.
Our focus is on making buying easy. The service is transparent and customer-centered.
With financing, reliable SUVs become affordable. Families find what they want within their budget.
Serving places like Cincinnati and Indianapolis, we reach a lot of customers. These areas know us well.
Choosing an SUV should excite you. At Tom Tepe Autocenter, we help make that happen with great financing choices.
Trade-In Your Current Vehicle
Trading in your old ride at Tom Tepe Autocenter is quick and easy—see how much you could save today.
How to Trade-In Your Vehicle at Tom Tepe Autocenter
Trading in your vehicle at Tom Tepe Autocenter is a straightforward process. We aim to make it quick and beneficial for you. Here are the steps to trade in your vehicle with us:
Clean your vehicle before bringing it in. This includes both inside and outside.
Gather all necessary documents like the title, service records, and registration.
Visit Tom Tepe Autocenter or Car Country for an in-person appraisal.
Our team uses real-time market data to assess your vehicle's value.
We consider factors like market demand, mileage, and maintenance history.
Minor repairs and professional cleaning can boost your car's trade-in value.
Use online tools like Kelley Blue Book for a rough value estimate ahead of time.
Bring your vehicle to us; the appraisal usually takes less than one hour.
Receive a fair, transparent offer based on the appraisal.
We accept all brands and models for trade-in, ensuring you get a competitive offer every
time.
Find Your Next Vehicle
Our team can help you find the right small SUV to fit your lifestyle. Start exploring a wide range of options at Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country today.
New Inventory at Tom Tepe Autocenter
Tom Tepe Autocenter features the most recent Chevrolet releases, like the 2025 Silverado and Equinox. Larger trucks such as the Silverado 2500 and 3500 HD serve drivers who require extra power or towing ability.
The website makes it simple to check all available models from home. Updates happen often, so shoppers see current options every time they visit online.
Customers can book a test drive for any vehicle listed in inventory. Every purchase comes with support from skilled sales staff who help you pick the right model for your needs across Indiana and Ohio communities.
Flexible financing is available upon credit approval for qualifying buyers interested in the most recent cars, crossovers, or trucks.
Quality Used SUVs at Tom Tepe Autocenter
Over 200 used vehicles fill our lot, with many Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 options for Indiana families. Our inventory also offers Chevrolet, Ford, Nissan, Ram, and GMC SUVs. Every SUV passes a full inspection and routine service before you see it.
Affordable pricing gives buyers more value on each vehicle.
Our team supports local drivers by providing dependable pre-owned sport utility vehicles at all locations in Indiana and nearby Ohio through Car Country. View the latest arrivals online or come in to schedule a test drive quickly.
“Each pre-owned SUV gets checked top to bottom for safety and quality before it joins our lineup,” says Harry Tepe.
Many shoppers prefer us for reliability and selection when looking for their next small SUV purchase or trade-in option. The next step is learning about financing choices made simple at Tom Tepe Autocenter.
Conclusion
The Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 both prove strong after 50,000 miles. The CR-V stands out for reliability and comfort, while the RAV4 impresses with power and more features. Each has its strengths for Indiana drivers searching for value in a used SUV.
Visit Tom Tepe Autocenter or Car Country to see which one fits your needs best. Our team is ready to help you make the right choice on your next ride.
FAQs
1. Which SUV is more reliable after 50,000 miles: the Honda CR-V or Toyota RAV4?Both models hold up well after 50k miles, but the Honda CR-V often scores slightly higher in reliability ratings and has lower average repair costs. The Toyota RAV4 is also very dependable, with strong results from J.D. Power and owner reviews.
2. How do maintenance costs compare between the CR-V and RAV4?The Honda CR-V averages about $407 annually for repairs, while the Toyota RAV4 averages around $429. Both are below the industry average for compact SUVs, so either is budget-friendly to maintain.
3. Does fuel economy differ much between the CR-V and RAV4?Yes. The gasoline versions are close in efficiency, but the Toyota RAV4 Hybrid has the edge with up to 40 MPG combined. The Honda CR-V Hybrid also performs well, making both models strong options for long commutes across Indiana.
4. Which SUV has more interior space and comfort?The Honda CR-V provides more passenger room and rear legroom, making it a better fit for taller families or frequent travelers. The RAV4 has a slightly smaller cabin but compensates with a rugged, adventure-focused design.
5. How do resale values compare between the CR-V and RAV4?Both SUVs retain value very well. The CR-V is praised for comfort and reliability, while the RAV4’s strong hybrid options and off-road trims drive demand. At Tom Tepe Autocenter & Car Country, trade-ins for both models typically bring competitive offers.
Harry Tepe, Owner and Dealer Principal, Tom Tepe Autocenter
Harry Tepe is a seasoned automotive expert and the owner of Tom Tepe Autocenter, a leading vehicle dealership serving the Midwest states of Ohio, Indiana, and Kentucky. With a lifelong passion for automobiles.
Over the years, Harry worked his way up through various roles, absorbing valuable insights into sales management and dealership operations until he became the youngest GM Dealer Principal and owner of Tom Tepe Autocenter, expanding the business to include multiple locations and a standalone reconditioning center.
Under Harry's leadership, Tom Tepe Autocenter and Car Country in Aurora and Harrison, Ohio, have grown exponentially, selling over 2000 vehicles annually and generating over $50 million in revenue. His active involvement in the industry is further evidenced by his participation in the NADA 20 Group and his influential role on the Board of Directors for the Indiana Auto Dealers Association, even serving as its President in 2016.
Harry's journey embodies the essence of expertise, authority, and trustworthiness. His insights and experiences are not just stories of personal growth and business success; they are testaments to his deep understanding of and commitment to the automotive industry.
Comments